Structured Interview Guide
Role | [Job title], [Department] |
Candidate | [Name] |
Interviewer(s) | [Names and roles] |
Interview stage | [Competency interview, 60 minutes] |
Date | [Date] |
Competencies assessed | Problem solving, Collaboration, Ownership, Communication, Role expertise |
1. Before the interview
Read the job description and the candidate’s application; note one or two areas to explore.
Confirm which competencies you are assessing; other panel members cover the rest.
Prepare a quiet room or video link and have this guide and a note-taking sheet ready.
2. Opening (5 minutes)
"Thank you for coming in, [Name]. I’m [Name], [role]. Over the next hour I’ll ask you about specific situations from your past experience. I’ll take notes so I can be fair to everyone we meet. Please use real examples and tell me what you did. We’ll leave ten minutes at the end for your questions. Does that sound OK?"
3. Competency questions (40 minutes)
Ask the main question, then use probes until you have the Situation, Task, Action and Result. Record evidence, not impressions.
3.1 Problem solving
Main question: Tell me about a time you faced a complex problem with no obvious solution. How did you approach it?
Probe: How did you work out what was causing the problem?
Probe: What options did you consider, and why did you choose the one you did?
Probe: What was the outcome, and how did you measure it?
3.2 Collaboration
Main question: Describe a situation where you had to work with someone whose approach was very different from yours.
Probe: What specifically made it difficult?
Probe: What did you do to make the working relationship effective?
Probe: What would you do differently next time?
3.3 Ownership
Main question: Tell me about a time something went wrong on a piece of work you were responsible for.
Probe: When did you realise there was a problem, and what did you do first?
Probe: Who did you tell, and how?
Probe: What changed afterwards as a result of what you learned?
3.4 Communication
Main question: Give me an example of when you had to explain something complicated to someone without your background.
Probe: How did you know whether they had understood?
Probe: What did you adjust when it was not landing?
3.5 Role expertise
Main question: [Role-specific question, e.g. "Walk me through how you would plan the first 90 days of a project to migrate our customer database."]
Probe: What risks would you look for first?
Probe: How would you know it was going well by day 30?
4. Rating scale
Rate each competency on evidence alone. Use whole numbers.
Score | Label | What the evidence looks like |
|---|---|---|
5 | Exceptional | Specific, complex example; clear personal actions; measurable result; reflects on learning and applies it more widely |
4 | Strong | Specific example with clear actions and a positive result; minor gaps |
3 | Meets the bar | Relevant example with reasonable actions; result or own role somewhat vague |
2 | Below the bar | General or hypothetical answer; unclear personal contribution; weak result |
1 | No evidence | No relevant example, or behaviour contrary to what the role needs |
5. Candidate questions (10 minutes)
Invite questions about the role, team and company. Answer honestly, including about challenges. Do not score this section unless it is a defined competency.
6. Close (5 minutes)
"Thank you, [Name]. Our next step is [stage] and we aim to get back to you by [date]. If you have any questions in the meantime, contact [recruiter name and email]."
7. Legal do’s and don’ts
Do ask about | Do not ask about |
|---|---|
Ability to perform the essential job duties, with or without accommodation | Health, disability or medical history |
Right to work in [country] (yes or no) | Nationality, birthplace or accent |
Availability for the required schedule | Marital status, pregnancy, children or childcare |
Relevant qualifications and licences | Age or graduation year |
Past work behaviour and results | Religion, politics, union membership |
Salary history [banned in many US states and cities] |
8. Scoring summary
Competency | Weight | Score (1–5) | Key evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
Problem solving | [25%] | ||
Collaboration | [20%] | ||
Ownership | [20%] | ||
Communication | [15%] | ||
Role expertise | [20%] | ||
Weighted total | 100% |
Overall recommendation: Strong hire / Hire / No hire (circle one)
Interviewer signature: ______________________ Date: [Date]
9. Debrief rules
Every interviewer submits scores before the debrief.
The hiring manager speaks last to avoid anchoring the group.
Discuss competencies where scores differ by 2 or more points first.
Decide on evidence against the agreed bar, not by comparing candidates’ personalities.
Record the decision and reasons in the applicant tracking system.