Skip to content
GraviPointThe Centre of Productivity
  • AI AgentNew
  • Pricing
  • Community
Log inGet started free
TemplatesHR & People ManagementRecruitment & HiringStructured Interview Guide

DocumentRecruitment & HiringFree

Structured Interview Guide

A competency-based interview guide with behavioural questions, follow-up probes, rating anchors and a fair debrief process.

Shown with sample data

Colour

Structured Interview Guide

Role

[Job title], [Department]

Candidate

[Name]

Interviewer(s)

[Names and roles]

Interview stage

[Competency interview, 60 minutes]

Date

[Date]

Competencies assessed

Problem solving, Collaboration, Ownership, Communication, Role expertise

1. Before the interview

  • Read the job description and the candidate’s application; note one or two areas to explore.

  • Confirm which competencies you are assessing; other panel members cover the rest.

  • Prepare a quiet room or video link and have this guide and a note-taking sheet ready.

2. Opening (5 minutes)

"Thank you for coming in, [Name]. I’m [Name], [role]. Over the next hour I’ll ask you about specific situations from your past experience. I’ll take notes so I can be fair to everyone we meet. Please use real examples and tell me what you did. We’ll leave ten minutes at the end for your questions. Does that sound OK?"

3. Competency questions (40 minutes)

Ask the main question, then use probes until you have the Situation, Task, Action and Result. Record evidence, not impressions.

3.1 Problem solving

Main question: Tell me about a time you faced a complex problem with no obvious solution. How did you approach it?

  • Probe: How did you work out what was causing the problem?

  • Probe: What options did you consider, and why did you choose the one you did?

  • Probe: What was the outcome, and how did you measure it?

3.2 Collaboration

Main question: Describe a situation where you had to work with someone whose approach was very different from yours.

  • Probe: What specifically made it difficult?

  • Probe: What did you do to make the working relationship effective?

  • Probe: What would you do differently next time?

3.3 Ownership

Main question: Tell me about a time something went wrong on a piece of work you were responsible for.

  • Probe: When did you realise there was a problem, and what did you do first?

  • Probe: Who did you tell, and how?

  • Probe: What changed afterwards as a result of what you learned?

3.4 Communication

Main question: Give me an example of when you had to explain something complicated to someone without your background.

  • Probe: How did you know whether they had understood?

  • Probe: What did you adjust when it was not landing?

3.5 Role expertise

Main question: [Role-specific question, e.g. "Walk me through how you would plan the first 90 days of a project to migrate our customer database."]

  • Probe: What risks would you look for first?

  • Probe: How would you know it was going well by day 30?

4. Rating scale

Rate each competency on evidence alone. Use whole numbers.

Score

Label

What the evidence looks like

5

Exceptional

Specific, complex example; clear personal actions; measurable result; reflects on learning and applies it more widely

4

Strong

Specific example with clear actions and a positive result; minor gaps

3

Meets the bar

Relevant example with reasonable actions; result or own role somewhat vague

2

Below the bar

General or hypothetical answer; unclear personal contribution; weak result

1

No evidence

No relevant example, or behaviour contrary to what the role needs

5. Candidate questions (10 minutes)

Invite questions about the role, team and company. Answer honestly, including about challenges. Do not score this section unless it is a defined competency.

6. Close (5 minutes)

"Thank you, [Name]. Our next step is [stage] and we aim to get back to you by [date]. If you have any questions in the meantime, contact [recruiter name and email]."

7. Legal do’s and don’ts

Do ask about

Do not ask about

Ability to perform the essential job duties, with or without accommodation

Health, disability or medical history

Right to work in [country] (yes or no)

Nationality, birthplace or accent

Availability for the required schedule

Marital status, pregnancy, children or childcare

Relevant qualifications and licences

Age or graduation year

Past work behaviour and results

Religion, politics, union membership

Salary history [banned in many US states and cities]

8. Scoring summary

Competency

Weight

Score (1–5)

Key evidence

Problem solving

[25%]

Collaboration

[20%]

Ownership

[20%]

Communication

[15%]

Role expertise

[20%]

Weighted total

100%

Overall recommendation: Strong hire / Hire / No hire (circle one)

Interviewer signature: ______________________ Date: [Date]

9. Debrief rules

  1. Every interviewer submits scores before the debrief.

  2. The hiring manager speaks last to avoid anchoring the group.

  3. Discuss competencies where scores differ by 2 or more points first.

  4. Decide on evidence against the agreed bar, not by comparing candidates’ personalities.

  5. Record the decision and reasons in the applicant tracking system.

Text in [brackets] is yours to replace.

  • About
  • What’s included
  • How to use
  • Questions
  • Related resources

About this template

Run interviews that are consistent, fair and predictive. This guide gives every interviewer the same structure: an opening script, five competency sections with behavioural questions and STAR follow-up probes, behaviourally anchored 1–5 rating scales, legal do and do-not guidance, candidate questions and a scoring summary for the debrief. Pair it with the Interview Scorecard to compare candidates.

Who it’s for

  • Panel interviews where several people assess the same candidate
  • Reducing bias and gut-feel hiring
  • Training new interviewers

What’s included

  • 1. Before the interview
  • 2. Opening (5 minutes)
  • 3. Competency questions (40 minutes)
  • 4. Rating scale
  • 5. Candidate questions (10 minutes)
  • 6. Close (5 minutes)
  • 7. Legal do’s and don’ts
  • 8. Scoring summary
  • 9. Debrief rules

How to use it

  1. 1Agree the 4–6 competencies that matter most for the role with the hiring manager before interviewing starts.
  2. 2Assign each interviewer a set of competencies so you do not ask the same questions twice.
  3. 3Ask every candidate the same main questions in the same order; use probes to get specific evidence.
  4. 4Score each competency independently right after the interview, before talking to other interviewers, then debrief.

Tips

  • Take notes on what the candidate said and did, not on your impression of them; ratings should be traceable to evidence.
  • Never ask about age, family plans, religion, health, nationality or other protected characteristics, even as small talk.
  • Give candidates the same time and the same information about the role, so differences in answers reflect them, not you.

Questions

What is a structured interview?

An interview where every candidate is asked the same job-related questions and their answers are scored against the same predefined rating scale. Research consistently shows structured interviews predict job performance better than unstructured conversations.

What is the STAR method?

Situation, Task, Action, Result. Behavioural questions ask about real past examples, and STAR probes ("What exactly did you do? What was the result?") draw out the specific evidence you need to score fairly.

How many questions should a structured interview have?

Usually 6–10 main questions in 45–60 minutes: one or two per competency, with time for probes and the candidate’s own questions.

Should interviewers discuss candidates before scoring?

No. Score independently first to avoid anchoring on the most senior or most vocal interviewer, then discuss differences in the debrief.

Related searchesstructured interview guidebehavioral interview questionscompetency based interviewstar interview questionsinterview guide templateinterview rating scale

Details

Format
Document
Category
Recruitment & Hiring
Setup
30 min
Level
Intermediate
Price
Free

Download a copy

Downloads need a free account.

DocumentRecruitment & HiringFree

Structured Interview Guide

A competency-based interview guide with behavioural questions, follow-up probes, rating anchors and a fair debrief process.

A free account keeps your copy safe so you can come back to it. Have one? Log in

Download a copy

Downloads need a free account.

Details

Format
Document
Category
Recruitment & Hiring
Setup
30 min
Level
Intermediate
Price
Free

Your copy is private to you.

More recruitment & hiring templates

View all
Applicant Tracking Sheet4 sheets

Active candidates

8

Stalled or overdue

8

Hires

1

Hiring funnel
13
11
7
3
1
AppliedScreenInterviewFinalOffer
SpreadsheetRecruitment & Hiring

Applicant Tracking Sheet

Candidates for every open role with stage, scores, next steps and stalled flags, plus a hiring funnel, time to hire and source quality.

10 min setupPreview
Interview Scorecard2 sheets

Interviews scored

6

Top score

90

Average score

75

Average score by candidate
88
77
61
Nadia OkaforLeo FischerInes Duarte
SpreadsheetRecruitment & Hiring

Interview Scorecard

Rate every candidate on the same competencies, weight what matters and compare them side by side.

10 min setupPreview

Job Title

Location: City / Remote · Type: Full-time · Team: Team · Salary: $X–$Y + benefits

About us

Two or three sentences about your mission, customers and culture.

The role

Why this role exists and the impact it will have.

What you'll do

  • •Responsibility with outcome
  • •Responsibility with outcome
  • •Responsibility with outcome
DocumentRecruitment & Hiring

Job Description

An inclusive, structured job description that attracts the right candidates.

30 min setupPreview

Practical guides and new resources, monthly.

One short email with new templates, calculators and how-tos. Unsubscribe any time.

GraviPointThe Centre of Productivity

Find the right resource. Make it work for you. Get things done with spreadsheets, documents, forms and calculators you can use right in your browser.

support@gravipoint.com
  • @gravipoint
  • @GraviPoint
  • GraviPoint
  • 𝕏@gravipoint

Templates

  • All templates
  • Budgets & expenses
  • Invoices & billing
  • Project management
  • HR & people
  • Inventory & stock
  • Sales & CRM
  • Financial calculators

Popular

  • Monthly budget
  • Invoice
  • Employee shift schedule
  • Weekly timesheet
  • Project plan & Gantt chart
  • Inventory tracker
  • Expense report
  • Mortgage calculator

Solutions

  • Individuals & households
  • Freelancers & consultants
  • Founders & startups
  • Small business owners
  • Teams & operations
  • Students & educators

Company

  • About
  • Features
  • Pricing
  • Community
  • Journal
  • Contact
© 2026 GraviPoint. All rights reserved.
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Help centre
  • FAQ