Root Cause Analysis Report
Reference | [RCA-2026-031] |
Site / department | [Meridian Foods Distribution Centre, Chilled Picking] |
Date opened | [3 November 2026] |
RCA lead | [Name, Quality Manager] |
Team | [Shift Manager, two senior pickers, WMS administrator, Customer Service Lead] |
Status | [Actions in progress] |
1. Problem statement
[Between 1 September and 31 October 2026, picking accuracy in the chilled section fell from 99.6% to 98.7%. 412 order lines were mis-picked, mostly wrong product variants (e.g. 500 g instead of 1 kg), leading to 63 customer complaints, $18,400 in credits and two retail customers issuing formal performance notices.]
2. Impact
Area | Impact |
|---|---|
Customer | [63 complaints; 2 formal notices from top-10 customers] |
Financial | [$18,400 credits plus $6,100 re-delivery cost] |
Operational | [Return handling and re-picks: about 90 labour hours] |
Safety / compliance | [None identified; no allergen substitutions] |
3. Containment
Action | Owner | Date | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
[100% check of chilled orders for top-10 customers before dispatch] | [Shift Manager] | [3 Nov] | [In place] |
[Separated look-alike variants onto different aisles as a temporary measure] | [Warehouse Lead] | [4 Nov] | [Done] |
4. Data gathered
[Errors by product: 71% involve 18 SKUs that come in two or more pack sizes with near-identical packaging]
[Errors by shift: night shift 2.1× the day-shift error rate]
[Errors by picker tenure: pickers with under 3 months’ service made 64% of errors]
[Slotting change on 28 August moved variants of the same product into adjacent locations to save travel time]
[Scanners on night shift: 6 of 20 handhelds had faulty triggers; pickers keyed location codes manually]
5. Fishbone (Ishikawa) analysis
Category | Possible causes identified | Likely? |
|---|---|---|
People | [High share of new pickers after summer hiring; shortened induction (2 days instead of 4)] | [Yes] |
Methods | [Pick confirmation by location scan only, not product barcode; slotting places variants side by side] | [Yes] |
Machines | [Faulty scanner triggers on night shift lead to manual key entry] | [Yes] |
Materials | [Supplier packaging for 500 g and 1 kg variants differs only in a small weight label] | [Yes] |
Measurement | [Accuracy report produced monthly, so the trend was spotted 6 weeks late] | [Contributing] |
Environment | [Lower lighting levels in two chilled aisles; pickers wear gloves, making labels harder to handle] | [Possible] |
6. 5 Whys
Cause chain 1: wrong variant picked
Why were wrong variants sent? [Pickers picked from the adjacent location holding the other pack size.]
Why was the error not caught at picking? [The system confirms the location barcode, not the product barcode.]
Why does it only confirm the location? [Product-barcode confirmation was switched off in 2024 to speed up picking.]
Why was it switched off without other controls? [The change was judged low-risk because variants were then stored in separate aisles.]
Why did the risk come back? [The August slotting change put variants side by side, and slotting changes are not risk-assessed against pick controls.]
Root cause 1: [Slotting changes are made without a check against error-proofing controls, so a change that saved travel time removed the separation that compensated for location-only scanning.]
Cause chain 2: higher error rate on night shift
Why is the night-shift error rate higher? [More manual key entry of location codes.]
Why more manual entry? [Six scanners have faulty triggers.]
Why were they not repaired? [Faults are reported verbally and not logged; no spare pool on nights.]
Root cause 2: [No equipment fault-reporting process or spare scanner pool for night shift.]
7. Verification of root causes
Root cause | Test | Result | Confirmed? |
|---|---|---|---|
[Slotting without control check] | [Compared error rate for variant SKUs before and after 28 Aug] | [0.3% before, 2.6% after] | [Yes] |
[Scanner faults] | [Error rate on lines picked with manual entry vs scanned] | [3.9% vs 0.8%] | [Yes] |
[Shortened induction] | [Error rate of new pickers with 2-day vs 4-day induction] | [Small difference once slotting controlled for] | [Contributing only] |
8. Corrective and preventive actions
# | Action | Type | Root cause | Owner | Due | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | [Turn on product-barcode confirmation for all multi-variant SKUs] | [Corrective] | [1] | [WMS Administrator] | [15 Nov 2026] | [Done] |
2 | [Re-slot variants at least one bay apart] | [Corrective] | [1] | [Warehouse Lead] | [22 Nov 2026] | [In progress] |
3 | [Add pick-control risk check to the slotting change procedure] | [Preventive] | [1] | [Operations Manager] | [30 Nov 2026] | [Open] |
4 | [Equipment fault log on every shift; 4 spare scanners on nights] | [Corrective] | [2] | [Shift Manager] | [20 Nov 2026] | [In progress] |
5 | [Ask supplier to add colour-coded pack-size bands] | [Preventive] | [Materials] | [Procurement] | [31 Jan 2027] | [Open] |
6 | [Restore 4-day induction with a variant-picking module] | [Preventive] | [People] | [Training Coordinator] | [1 Dec 2026] | [Open] |
7 | [Weekly accuracy report by zone and shift] | [Preventive] | [Measurement] | [Quality Manager] | [15 Nov 2026] | [Done] |
8 | [Apply the same review to the ambient and frozen sections] | [Preventive] | [1, 2] | [Operations Manager] | [31 Dec 2026] | [Open] |
9. Effectiveness check
Measure | Baseline | Target | Check date | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
[Chilled picking accuracy] | [98.7%] | [99.6% or better for 8 consecutive weeks] | [31 Jan 2027] | [ ] |
[Customer complaints for wrong variant] | [32 a month] | [Under 3 a month] | [31 Jan 2027] | [ ] |
[Lines picked with manual key entry] | [9%] | [Under 1%] | [15 Dec 2026] | [ ] |
10. Lessons learned
[Any change to layout or slotting must be checked against the controls that depend on it.]
[Weekly measurement would have caught the trend within two weeks instead of six.]
11. Sign-off
Role | Name | Date |
|---|---|---|
RCA lead | [Name] | [Date] |
Operations Manager | [Name] | [Date] |
Closed by (after effectiveness check) | [Name] | [Date] |