[Your Full Name]
[Street address] · [City, State ZIP] · [Phone] · [Email]
Sent by [certified mail / fax to number / member portal upload]
[Date]
[Appeals Department]
[Insurance Company Name] · [Street address] · [City, State ZIP]
Re: First-level appeal of claim denial
Patient / insured | [Patient Full Name], date of birth [MM/DD/YYYY] |
Policyholder (if different) | [Name] |
Member ID / policy number | [number] |
Group number | [number] |
Claim number | [number] |
Date(s) of service | [date] |
Provider | [Dr. Name, Practice / Hospital] |
Date of denial notice | [date] |
Dear Appeals Reviewer,
I am writing to appeal your decision to deny coverage for [an MRI of the lumbar spine] performed on [date], as set out in your letter dated [date]. I ask that you reverse the denial and pay the claim in full.
Your letter states that the claim was denied because: "[The service is not medically necessary. Conservative treatment of at least six weeks was not documented.]"
This decision is incorrect for the following reasons:
Conservative treatment was completed and documented. As the enclosed records show, I completed [eight weeks of physical therapy between date and date (14 sessions)] and took [prescription anti-inflammatory medication] throughout, without improvement. These records were [sent with the original claim / are enclosed again].
The MRI meets your own clinical criteria. Your medical policy [name and number, e.g. "Imaging of the Spine, MP-204"] states that lumbar MRI is medically necessary where [radicular symptoms persist after six weeks of conservative therapy or where there are progressive neurological deficits]. My physician documented both [persistent sciatica and new weakness in my left foot on date].
My physician confirms medical necessity. The enclosed letter from [Dr. Name], [specialty], explains why the MRI was needed to [rule out nerve compression requiring surgery], and that delaying it risked [permanent nerve damage].
The policy covers this service. Section [number] of my [Evidence of Coverage / policy] lists [diagnostic imaging] as a covered benefit when medically necessary, with no exclusion that applies here.
I request that you:
Reverse the denial and pay the claim of [$2,140.00] in accordance with my plan benefits.
Ensure this appeal is reviewed by a [physician / clinical reviewer] with expertise in [orthopaedics or neurology] who was not involved in the original decision.
Send me, free of charge, copies of all documents, records and criteria relied on in deciding my claim, including the name and credentials of the reviewer.
Send your written decision within the time required by [law / my plan].
If the denial is upheld, please tell me in writing how to request an external review and the deadline for doing so. I am also prepared to contact [the State Department of Insurance / my employer's plan administrator] if necessary.
Thank you for your prompt review.
Sincerely,
[Signature]
[Your Full Name]
Enclosures: [Copy of denial letter dated date; letter of medical necessity from Dr. Name; physical therapy records; relevant medical records and imaging report; copy of insurer's medical policy MP-204; relevant pages of my policy; itemised bill]
Optional paragraphs
Expedited (urgent) appeal: I request an expedited appeal. My physician has certified that waiting for a standard appeal could seriously jeopardise my life, health or ability to regain maximum function, as explained in the enclosed letter. Please decide this appeal within 72 hours.
Property or car claim denial: You denied my claim [number] for [storm damage to my roof] on the ground that the damage was caused by [wear and tear]. The enclosed report from [licensed roofing contractor / independent adjuster], dated [date], confirms that the damage is consistent with [wind and hail from the storm of date], which is a covered peril under section [number] of my policy. Weather data for my area on that date is also enclosed.
Request for external review: I have exhausted your internal appeals process; your final denial is dated [date]. Under [applicable state or federal law], I request an independent external review of this decision. Please forward my file to the independent review organisation and confirm when you have done so.