A manager’s evaluation form rating core competencies and goals, with evidence, an overall rating and development actions.
Shown with sample data
Colour
About this template
A structured, fair evaluation in one form. Managers rate eight core competencies on a defined five-point scale, assess progress against the period’s goals, give evidence for strengths and development areas, choose an overall rating, set goals and development actions for the next period, and capture the employee’s comments and acknowledgment.
Who it’s for
Mid-year and annual evaluations
Frontline and hourly teams that need a simple form
Organisations moving from paper appraisals to digital
What’s included
Employee details (6 fields)
Competency ratings (8 fields)
Goals and evidence (4 fields)
Next period (2 fields)
Comments and acknowledgment (2 fields)
How to use it
1Gather evidence for the period first: goals, results, feedback from others and the employee’s self-appraisal.
2Rate each competency against the scale definitions, not against other employees.
3Write at least one specific example for the overall rating and each development area.
4Discuss the evaluation in person, agree next-period goals and collect the employee’s acknowledgment.
Tips
Watch for recency bias: look at the whole review period, not just the last few weeks.
Use the employee’s Self-Appraisal Form as input so the conversation is two-way.
Ratings drive pay and promotion decisions; calibrate them with other managers before sharing.
Questions
What should an employee evaluation include?
Ratings on job-relevant competencies, progress against goals, specific examples, an overall rating, goals and development actions for the next period, and the employee’s comments.
How often should employees be evaluated?
At least annually, with a mid-year check-in. Many teams now add quarterly conversations so the annual evaluation holds no surprises.
What rating scale is best?
A five-point scale with clear definitions is the most common. What matters most is that every manager uses the same definitions and calibrates ratings.