FI number
$1,250,000
Savings rate
43%
Years to FI
15
FIRE Early Retirement Planner
Your FI number, savings rate, years to financial independence, Coast FI and a year-by-year path to retiring early.
SpreadsheetFinancial PlanningFree
Total cost of driving the same car three ways: lease, buy with a loan or pay cash, including depreciation and lost interest.
Shown with sample data
Total cost of driving the same car three ways: lease, buy with a loan or pay cash, including depreciation and lost interest.
Comparing a lease payment with a loan payment is misleading: one leaves you with a car and the other does not. This workbook compares the full cost of driving for the same period: up-front cash, monthly payments, fees, excess mileage, maintenance, any loan balance still owed, the interest your cash could have earned, minus what the car is worth at the end.
Leasing usually costs less over two to three years and suits people who want a new car often and drive average miles. Buying usually wins if you keep the car five years or more, because you stop making payments while still owning a car with value.
Up-front cash, monthly payments, fees, excess mileage, maintenance after warranty, loan balance owed at the end, interest your up-front cash could have earned, and the car’s value at the end (subtracted for the buy options).
Look up the residual value in the lease quote (often 50–60% after three years) or check used prices for the same model at that age. Typical figures: about 60% after 3 years, 45% after 5, 30% after 7.
The lease side assumes you lease again on similar terms, paying due-at-signing and fees for each lease.
Download a copy
Downloads need a free account.