[Hybrid Working Pilot: Evaluation and Recommendations]
Prepared for | [Executive Committee, Calder & Moss Consulting] |
Prepared by | [Name, People Analytics Lead] |
Date | [14 December 2026] |
Report reference | [EXCO-2026-41] |
Classification | [Internal] |
Executive summary
[From April to September 2026, 142 staff in three practices worked a hybrid pattern of three office days and two remote days. This report evaluates the pilot against its objectives. Billable utilisation was unchanged (74.2% vs 74.6% in the comparison group), voluntary turnover in the pilot group fell to 9% annualised against 17%, and 86% of pilot staff want to continue. Client satisfaction was stable. Office desk use averaged 58%, creating an opportunity to release one floor. We recommend adopting hybrid working firm-wide from April 2027 with anchor days per team, investing $180,000 in meeting-room technology and reviewing the property strategy.]
1. Introduction
1.1 Purpose
[To evaluate the hybrid working pilot and recommend whether, and how, to extend it.]
1.2 Terms of reference
[Assess the pilot’s impact on productivity, client satisfaction, staff retention and wellbeing, and office use.]
[Identify problems and how they could be addressed.]
[Recommend a firm-wide approach with costs.]
[Out of scope: changes to employment contracts and pay, which HR will address separately.]
1.3 Background
[Exit interviews in 2025 showed flexibility as the second most common reason for leaving. The Executive Committee approved a six-month pilot in February 2026.]
2. Methodology
Source | Details |
|---|---|
[Utilisation data] | [Timesheets for pilot (142) and comparison group (156), April–September, vs the same period in 2025] |
[Staff surveys] | [Baseline in March and follow-up in September; 88% response rate] |
[Client feedback] | [Quarterly client satisfaction scores for 64 accounts] |
[Office data] | [Desk-booking and badge data] |
[Focus groups] | [Six groups, 41 participants, including managers] |
Limitations: [Practices were not randomly assigned; the pilot ran through summer when utilisation is normally lower; six months is short for turnover analysis.]
3. Findings
3.1 Productivity
Measure | Pilot group | Comparison group |
|---|---|---|
[Billable utilisation] | [74.2%] | [74.6%] |
[Change vs 2025] | [+0.8 points] | [+0.5 points] |
[Projects delivered on time] | [88%] | [86%] |
[There was no meaningful difference in productivity measures.]
3.2 Retention and wellbeing
Measure | Pilot group | Comparison group |
|---|---|---|
[Voluntary turnover (annualised)] | [9%] | [17%] |
["I can balance work and personal life" (agree)] | [81% (up from 52%)] | [55% (up from 53%)] |
[Average commuting time saved per week] | [4.6 hours] | [n/a] |
3.3 Client satisfaction
[Average client satisfaction was 8.4 out of 10 for pilot accounts and 8.3 for others. Two clients asked for more on-site presence during workshops; both were resolved by scheduling.]
3.4 Collaboration and development
[Focus groups reported that junior staff learned less on remote days and that mixed in-person and remote meetings worked poorly in rooms without proper cameras and microphones. 64% of managers said ad hoc coaching had become harder.]
3.5 Office use
[Desk occupancy averaged 58% across the week, peaking at 81% on Tuesdays and falling to 22% on Fridays.]
4. Conclusions
[Hybrid working did not reduce productivity or client satisfaction.]
[It substantially improved staff wellbeing and appears to reduce turnover; at the firm’s average replacement cost of $38,000 per leaver, the turnover difference is worth about $1.1m a year across the firm.]
[Junior development and meeting quality are the main weaknesses and need deliberate fixes.]
[Current office space exceeds need on most days.]
5. Recommendations
# | Recommendation | Owner | Cost | Timing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | [Adopt hybrid working firm-wide: three office days, including two team anchor days] | [Managing Partner] | [None] | [From April 2027] |
2 | [Equip 14 meeting rooms for hybrid meetings] | [IT Director] | [$180,000] | [By March 2027] |
3 | [Require juniors in their first 12 months to be in the office four days, with structured coaching] | [Head of Talent] | [Time] | [From April 2027] |
4 | [Review property: sublet or release one of three floors at lease break] | [COO] | [Saving est. $420,000 a year] | [Decision by June 2027] |
5 | [Track utilisation, turnover and engagement quarterly for the first year] | [People Analytics Lead] | [Time] | [Quarterly] |
6. Next steps
[If the Executive Committee approves, HR will issue the policy and consult staff in January, IT will procure meeting-room equipment in February and the COO will report on property options in June.]
References
[Internal: Hybrid Working Pilot Plan, February 2026]
[Internal: Exit Interview Analysis 2025]
[External source, author, title, year]
Appendices
[A. Survey questions and full results]
[B. Utilisation data by practice and month]
[C. Focus group themes]
[D. Meeting-room equipment quote]