A3 Problem-Solving Report: [Scrap Rate on Line 2 Injection Moulding]
Owner | [Problem owner name, role] |
Coach / sponsor | [Name, role] |
Team | [Moulding technician, quality engineer, setter, materials planner] |
Start date | [6 Oct 2026] |
Last updated | [17 Nov 2026] |
Status | [Check: results being measured] |
1. Background
Why does this problem matter now? Two or three sentences. Line 2 moulds the [ID-40 cover] for our largest customer. Scrap rose from a stable 1.8% to 4.6% over the last quarter, costing about [$11,200] a month in material and machine time and putting the [weekly 18,000-unit] schedule at risk.
2. Current condition
Go and see. Show the facts and the gap to the standard.
Measure | Standard / target | Current (Sep 2026) | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
Scrap rate | 2.0% | 4.6% | 2.6 points |
Short shots (share of scrap) | Not tracked | 58% | Main defect |
Unplanned stops per shift | 1 | 3.4 | 2.4 |
Material moisture at press | ≤ 0.02% | 0.04–0.07% | Over limit |
A Pareto of 1,240 rejected parts showed short shots 58%, splay 21%, flash 12%, other 9%.
Short shots cluster in the first two hours after a material change and on night shift.
The dryer hopper was refilled by hand at night because the vacuum loader was faulty.
3. Target
Reduce Line 2 scrap from 4.6% to 2.0% or less by [31 Dec 2026], and hold it for four consecutive weeks.
4. Root cause analysis
5 Whys: short shots
Why? | Answer | Verified by |
|---|---|---|
1. Why are parts short? | Material does not fill the last cavity | Cavity pressure trace |
2. Why does it not fill? | Melt viscosity is too high at the start of the run | Melt flow index test |
3. Why is viscosity high? | Resin is not dried to spec (0.05% moisture) | Moisture analyser, 12 samples |
4. Why is it not dried? | Night shift loads wet resin straight into the hopper while the loader is down | Shift interviews, loader fault log |
5. Why is the loader down? | No PM task exists for the loader filter; it blocks every 5–6 weeks | CMMS history |
Fishbone categories checked
Man: night shift not trained on manual drying time (verified).
Machine: vacuum loader filter blocks; no PM (verified, root cause).
Material: resin moisture over limit when hand-filled (verified).
Method: no standard for drying time after a material change (verified, root cause).
Measurement: moisture tested once per shift only (contributing).
Environment: humidity higher at night (minor; not a driver once drying is controlled).
5. Countermeasures
# | Countermeasure | Root cause addressed | Owner | Due | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Add a 4-weekly PM task to clean and replace the loader filter | No PM on loader | [Maintenance lead] | [24 Oct] | Done |
2 | Standard work: 4 h minimum drying after every material change, with a timer on the dryer | No drying standard | [Process engineer] | [31 Oct] | Done |
3 | Moisture test at start-up and every 4 hours, logged on the press check sheet | Measurement frequency | [Quality engineer] | [7 Nov] | Done |
4 | Train all three shifts on drying standard and loader faults | Night shift training | [Team leaders] | [14 Nov] | In progress |
6. Implementation plan
Week | Activity | Who |
|---|---|---|
43 | Loader PM added to CMMS; first filter change | Maintenance |
44 | Drying standard written, trialled on day shift | Process engineering |
45 | Moisture checks added to press check sheet | Quality |
46–47 | Training on all shifts; audit compliance daily | Team leaders |
7. Results (check)
Week | Scrap rate | Short shots | Moisture in spec |
|---|---|---|---|
Baseline (Sep) | 4.6% | 58% of scrap | 40% of tests |
Week 45 | 3.1% | 41% | 78% |
Week 46 | 2.2% | 24% | 95% |
Week 47 | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] |
8. Follow-up (act)
Update the PFMEA and control plan for moisture and loader failure.
Roll the drying standard and loader PM out to Lines 1 and 4 (same resin family).
Review the results at the [January] operations review; close the A3 after four weeks at or below target.
Lesson learned: equipment that only fails occasionally still needs a PM task.